Cymraeg

Skip to content

Wales: a community of communities

Myfanwy Davies looks at how Independence would affect her community – Llanelli

It has become popular to say that Wales is a community of communities and in miniature, my Wales streches from Hendy high above the Loughor in the East to the industrial villages of Ty Croes and the Gwendraeth down to Llanelli, Burry Port and Kidwelly strung along the Burry Estuary. This is the Wales I love most and want to serve.

I want Wales to be independent because only by making our own decisions as a nation can we get a fair deal for Llanelli and other similar communities. Only through independence can we play the role we need to play in the wider world.

Part of me believes in independence for its own sake.

It would serve to heal the wounds of hundreds of years of exploitation and forced subservience. A Welsh declaration of independence would put a full stop on the sorry history of parents refusing to hand on the language to their children as if it was a mark of Cain that would make them less intelligent, less capable and less talented than others.

An independent Wales would realize the dreams of the workers who built the chapels and workingmen’s halls that were the first civic institutions in their communities. Independence will make us stand taller but it is also about much more than that. Independence is about the survival of our communities in a world facing a global financial crisis where irresponsible decisions in London put them at risk.

We may face cuts of up to £500m in public spending in Wales next year. This comes on top of the injustice of the Barnett formula which calculates the Assembly budget based on a head count rather than an assessment of needs. The reason for this new round of cuts is that the bank bailouts will have to be paid for.

Llanelli has hundreds of manufacturing jobs under threat; some of them have been saved by the Assembly Government’s “ProAct” scheme. We have seen a huge rise in repossessions in Llanelli from the start of the crisis and without a doubt the Assembly’s mortgage rescue scheme and the £1 million set aside to finish affordable housing projects in the county will have helped people to keep their homes. The funding behind these schemes is a tiny fraction of the £50bn that has already been channelled into banks which has had little effect on borrowers and small business owners in Llanelli who are still seeing overdrafts called in where they have met all their repayments.

The public sector provides more jobs pro rata in Wales than it does in other parts of the UK and so these cuts will have a bigger impact here. They will fatally undermine efforts to promote the market in goods and services in Wales’ poorest communities, places like Llanelli where the economy is still much less developed than in other regions of Wales and the EU despite a second round of funding intended to close that gap. I believe that safeguarding jobs in the public sector now has to be the UK government’s priority but even if my MP agreed with me, and even if all the Welsh MPs agreed with me, they would still be only 40 voices among 600.

Welsh MPs of course do not act as a block as the majority need to follow their London-based bosses. Nonetheless, when the Liverpool corporation wanted to drown the Tryweryn Valley to supply water for the city, our Welsh MPs did vote together, but the simple arithmetic of Westminster meant that their views did not count. Tryweryn of course was drowned and its people resettled.

If we as the people of Wales believe that we have a shared experience and shared values, how can we possibly believe that the Westminster Parliament can represent us?

Independence is not about closing out the world. It is about coming of age on our own terms and now more than ever it is about protecting ourselves and each other.

In common with other towns in Wales, our town centres in Llanelli and Burry Port have been haemorrhaging businesses as larger shops move to out-of-town sites. The Sustainable Communities Act 2007 is a piece of England-only legislation that enables County Councils and local people to decide on strategies to promote local businesses, affordable housing and to draw down funds to drive those strategies forwards. If we want to be able to use these powers the Assembly will need to submit a Legislative Competency Order. These orders ask Westminster for the powers to make decisions on issues that are within the Assembly’s remit. Currently the process of deciding on Legislative Competency Orders or LCOs involves no fewer than 27 steps. This is a ridiculous situation where an LCO on assessing the needs of carers for social service support took two years to process. During that time, families I know were under the intolerable strain of providing round-the-clock care with no respite or support services provided by the County Council because their needs had not been assessed. Our Assembly, voted for by us, needs the tools to make decisions that affect us and our communities now, not in two years’ time. The situation we currently have is indefensible, because it rests on an assumption that our law-makers are not competent to make the same decisions that MPs make.

Of course we can make our own decisions. We have never needed our hand held by Westminster and we have proven through the sensible steps taken by the Assembly Government to address the economic crisis that we are more than competent to govern ourselves.

I don’t think a person chooses their national identity entirely freely. A person’s upbringing, their education and the opportunities they have in life play a role in the identities they take on. Nonetheless, I do believe in Gwynfor Evans’ phrase that that being Welsh is a choice you are free to make if you are happy to live with the consequences. If we are to take our place in the world on our own terms, the consequences of being Welsh mean that we take responsibility for governing ourselves. We need to come out from the shadow of Westminster that has starved economic growth in Wales by cutting off public spending and has starved us of the opportunity of making decisions that fundamentally affect the way people live in Wales. The working men and women who built our first institutions knew that to create opportunities in their communities to educate, to debate, to be creative, they had to step out of the shadow of a system that said they were only workers and act as thinking members of a community and a nation.

Only by making our own decisions in an independent Wales can we look after ourselves and each other. It is time to step out into the sun.

Myfanwy Davies

Help us build the WalesCan generation today. Your donation will help the campaign for independence.

Donate Today

Copy the following code to embed the video

Recent comments

Currently only displaying English comments.

  • Name
    MH ( 4-April-2009, 08:55 pm) §
    Comment
    Owain, you say we need more wealth creating jobs. I'm not quite sure that I'd put retail in that category, but manufacturing certainly is.
    -
    Of course, the amount of the UK's GVA (Gross Value Added, a measure of wealth production) that comes from manufacturing has declined steadily over the last few decades but Wales did, and still does, produce a greater proportion of its wealth from manufacturing than any other part of the UK.
    -
    In 2006 manufacturing was responsible for 17.88% of Wales' GVA, compared with 13.34% for the UK as a whole (13.04% England, 13.92% Scotland, 15.38% NI).
    -
    http://www.statistics.gov.uk/downloads/theme_economy/PROGRESS_NUTS1.xls
    -
    So on that measure Wales is quite capable of being successful as an independent country.
  • Name
    Owain (13-March-2009, 12:18 am) §
    Comment
    Quote from Myfanwy Davies "The public sector provides more jobs pro rata in Wales than it does in other parts of the UK and so these cuts will have a bigger impact here."
    But, public sector jobs don't create wealth, we need more wealth creating jobs in manufacturing/retail etc. for Wales to be successfull as an independent country.
  • Name
    Iago Ap Steffan (12-March-2009, 08:33 am) §
    Comment
    It will deffinately benefit all areas of Wales, giving our cities, towns and villages a bigger say on how we should be governed and whether we should waste money on illegal wars or nuclear weapons and subs. It will also give them a louder voice in Europe and the world. It may not be the loudest, but it will deffinately be a lot louder than what it is now. Gwenllian, I believe many people will want to discuss and get their views across, whether positive or negative, at least it will be discussed. : )
  • Name
    Rhydian Fôn James (11-March-2009, 10:21 am) §
    Comment
    Dave Jones: You and me both. I am dedicating my life to this cause!
  • Name
    DAVE JONES (10-March-2009, 10:23 pm) §
    Comment
    JUST HAD A BROWSE OF THE WEBSITE.BEEN A MEMBER FOR ONLY 2 YEARS ,WISH I JOINED YEARS AGO.PLAID CAN MAKE A BIG SURGE FORWARD.I AM 40 YEARS OLD AND I HOPE TO SEE WALES GAIN INDEPENDANCE BEFORE I RETIRE.

Add a comment

Contribute to the debate and make your voice heard. Complete the form to add a comment.




  1. Your e-mail will never be shared with third parties. Privacy Policy



  2. We check to prevent spamming

Note: Fields marked * are mandatory fields.

We won't share your details with anyone else.

We are the WalesCan Generation

The time of Wales being held back by its lack of self-confidence is ending. Our nation is growing in confidence with every generation. This is not the Wales Cannot Generation. This is the WalesCan Generation – The Independence Generation.

I Believe Wales Can

Add your voice to ours. Don’t just wish for a better Wales – help make a better Wales. Join the Independence Initiative.



Spread the word

Add your friends’ voices to yours. Ask your friend to join with you and the Independence Initiative.



  1. Separate the e-mail addresses with commas.



  2. You can customise this message to send to your friends
Donate to WalesCan